It's Sunday morning and you've made a decision.
This week you are going to be good!
Breakfast is planned, lunch is a big salad, and there is nothing in the cupboard that might call to you after dinner.
By Wednesday you are running on coffee and good intentions, and by Friday night, somewhere between the challah and the second helping of kugel, it all falls apart. Then the cake comes out after Shabbat lunch, and the familiar voice arrives right on time, telling you that you've ruined the whole week and that Sunday is the day to get back on track.
If this sounds familiar, I really get it. It is one of the things I hear most often in my clinic, usually from capable, intelligent women who know exactly what they "should" be eating and despite this feel like any willpower or motivation to stop themselves from all the delicious food is futile. Yet at the same time they are desperate to finally fit back into their clothes.
It is confusing and frustrating, and it can leave you feeling as though you simply can't be trusted around food (which is not true, and I'll explain why).
Why does my eating fall apart on Shabbat after being "good" all week?
Very often, what happens on Friday night begins on Sunday morning. When you eat less and hold tight to a list of rules all week, your body arrives at Shabbat hungry, tired and running on empty, and a table full of food you love meets a body that has been waiting all week to be properly fed.
Every week we are blessed to have Shabbat, but with it comes cooking for a full house, tasting as you go on Friday afternoon because there was no time for lunch, the challah and the kiddush, the second helpings because everyone is having seconds, and often if the food is right there in front of you, you are having it without even thinking. One of the hardest times can be the cake with Shabbat afternoon tea, and of course the leftovers on Sunday so nothing goes to waste.
So what is actually happening in your body? When you have eaten less than your body needs for several days, your blood sugar dips more easily and your stress hormones rise to keep you going. Cortisol helps release stored glucose so you have energy to get through the day, and when that energy runs low your body starts asking loudly for the quickest fuel it can find, which is why sweet things and bread suddenly feel impossible to resist. A craving that is satisfied pays you within seconds, and your brain records that loudly. Dopamine increases, and you have a momentary feeling of relief.
This is your body doing exactly what it was designed to do. The body is very clever. It is protecting you from what it reads as a shortage, and it has no idea that the shortage was planned on a Sunday morning with the best of intentions.
Whose voice is in your head about food?
Many of the women I work with are carrying someone else's voice around with them, and often more than one. It might sound like "Finish your plate, there are starving children in Africa". or "Don't eat after seven." or "Carbs at night are the enemy." or "Don't you think you've had enough?"
I still remember being 18 and living with a host family in Germany, where I spent a year as an exchange student. My host mother had a box of the most delicious praline chocolates on the table. After offering me one, she turned to me and said, "A minute on the lips, a year on the hips."
It is remarkable how one sentence like that can stay with you for years.
Some of the rules we have about food and eating come from a mother or grandmother, some from the slimming clubs and low-fat years many of us grew up in, some from a magazine, a doctor's passing comment, or the plan a friend swore by last summer.
In so many Jewish homes, food was love. It was offered with a full heart, and it still is. And yet, for many of us, in the very same breath came comments about our bodies, about who was eating too much or who had "let herself go". So we learned to feed everyone with love while watching ourselves with suspicion, and that is a confusing thing to carry into every family meal.
These beliefs were created to protect us, and many of them served us at one point in time. When they are no longer relevant, though, they can end up running the show. This is why, when I first start working with a client, we look at the food rules she has believed to be true and gently ask where each one came from. It opens a space to look at food and nourishment with fresh eyes.
Why do food rules feel louder in perimenopause and menopause?
In midlife the rules that once seemed to work often stop working, and the natural response is to hold on to them even tighter. As oestrogen and progesterone shift, many women notice changes in sleep, energy, mood and where their body carries weight, and it often feels like your body has simply changed overnight (through no fault of your own!).
I understand this from the inside too, because even with all of my nutrition knowledge and years of experience, when I turned 44, the same things happened to me.
At the same time, your load is heavier than it has ever been. You have work, family, ageing parents, perhaps children in the army or leaving home, and here in Israel, the weight of the war on top of it all. In a 2025 survey of Israeli women, 71% reported more stress and anxiety, 70% reported changes in sleep and 65% reported changes in their eating, mainly more sweets and carbohydrates (Women and Their Bodies). If that is you, you are far from alone.
When a body that is already under more stress is given less food and more rules, the emotional side of eating tends to grow louder rather than quieter. It does not mean that you have no willpower. It means you have fallen into the trap of what you think eating should be, using an approach that was never designed for the body you live in now. This is the time of life for you to eat smarter, not less.
What happens when you try to control your eating from the outside?
The dieting mindset teaches us to look outside ourselves for permission to eat. Things like the clock, the app, the plan, the number on the scale on Monday morning, or the rule about no bread after Shabbat lunch. Each of these asks you to override what your body is telling you, and over time you stop hearing the signals at all.
The scale deserves a special mention, because for so many women it decides the mood of the whole day before breakfast has even begun. It cannot tell you how you slept, how much energy you have at 4pm, whether your digestion is comfortable or how you feel in your own skin, and yet it often gets the final say.
There is another cost that is easy to miss. Every time a strict rule breaks under the pressure of normal life, it registers, often without us realising, as breaking a promise to ourselves. After enough of those moments you are left self-critical, judging and mistrusting yourself, and further away from where you truly want to be. I am openly challenging the idea that the answer is to try harder. Trying harder with an approach that no longer fits is exactly what keeps the Sunday to Shabbat cycle turning.
How can I stop feeling out of control around food on Shabbat?
Instead of forcing your body to cooperate with rules that no longer work, I'd love for you to get curious and treat the next few weeks as an experiment. Be an observer, not a judge. You are simply gathering information about what your body needs now. Here are three small places you can start, and I encourage you to choose just one.
Look upstream at your week. If Friday night feels like the moment everything unravels, reflect back on your Thursday and Friday before you look at the Shabbat meal itself. Were you eating enough? Did you have a balanced breakfast and lunch on Friday, or were you tasting your way through the cooking on an empty stomach? Arriving at Shabbat nourished rather than ravenous gives your body far less reason to shout.
Question one food rule. Write down one rule that runs through your head, and ask yourself whose voice it is, when you first heard it, and whether it is true for your body today. You don't have to throw it away. Just try life without it on for size for a week and notice what happens.
Pause once at the Shabbat meal. Before the main course, take a breath and ask yourself how you want to feel after this meal, not only tonight but tomorrow morning too. Then enjoy the challah, enjoy the dessert, and let it be part of the meal rather than something to make up for later. Pair rather than cut, adding some protein and vegetables alongside the foods you love, so your blood sugar stays steadier and the cake on Shabbat afternoon feels like a choice rather than a pull.
And if you do end up eating far more than you wanted, the next step is simply the next meal. There is no need to make up for it with a smaller breakfast or a stricter week, because that is exactly what sets up next Friday night. Honestly though, one Shabbat doesn't undo a week of nourishing your body, and the meals you share with the people you love are part of a nourished life. The way forward has to make room for them.
It's time to work in partnership with your body
This way of eating, guided by curiosity and by what your body is communicating rather than by rules borrowed from someone else, sits at the heart of the WISE Method™, the approach I use with every woman I work with. It brings together clinical nutrition, mindset and nervous system support, so you can understand what your body is asking for and rebuild trust in yourself one small promise at a time.
This doesn't happen overnight, but like anything worth investing in, progress is built one small choice at a time.
If you would like support to make peace with food and work in partnership with your body, you can find out more about how I work with women in midlife on my website.
Find out how we can work together
Frequently asked questions
Is it normal to overeat on Shabbat? Yes, it is very common, especially if you have eaten less during the week. Shabbat brings together hunger, tiredness, emotion and a table full of food you love, so your body is responding to all of it at once. It says nothing about your character and a great deal about how the week before was set up.
Should I eat less during the week to make up for Shabbat? I'd gently encourage you not to. Eating less to compensate tends to leave your body depleted by Friday, which makes Shabbat feel even harder. Eating balanced, satisfying meals through the week gives you a calmer, steadier start to Shabbat.
Why do I crave sweet things on Shabbat afternoon? After a large lunch, a busy week and often a short night's sleep, your energy naturally dips in the afternoon and your body looks for quick fuel. Tiredness and the comfort of the ritual play a part too. Getting curious about how you slept and what you ate earlier in the day often tells you more than the craving itself.
Can emotional eating get worse in perimenopause and menopause? For many women it does. Changes in sleep, stress hormones and blood sugar regulation in midlife can make cravings feel stronger, and trying to eat less to compensate often makes the emotional pull louder. Understanding what has changed in your body is the first step to easing it.
How do I handle comments about food at family meals? You can decide what you want to eat before the meal and let that guide you, rather than the comments around you. A warm, simple response such as "I'm happy with what I have, thank you" is enough. Your body and your choices belong to you, whoever is passing the plate.